From authentic New York-style slices and crispy Detroit squares to wood-fired Italian pizzas and neighborhood favorites, Greater Orlando has some outstanding places to satisfy a pizza craving.

Let’s settle something.

Finding good pizza in Orlando isn’t difficult anymore.

Finding the best pizza? That’s where the arguments begin.

Ask someone who grew up in Brooklyn, and they’ll probably tell you that a proper pizza needs a thin crust, a generous layer of mozzarella and enough flexibility to fold a slice in half.

Ask someone who loves Detroit-style pizza, and they’ll insist that a thick, airy crust with crispy, caramelized cheese around the edges is impossible to beat.

Then there’s the traditional Italian pizza enthusiast, who wants a wood-fired crust, fresh mozzarella, basil and a beautifully balanced tomato sauce.

Fortunately, Greater Orlando has all three, plus plenty of creative variations.

And some of the most interesting places aren’t in the tourist districts at all.

They’re tucked into neighborhoods like Curry Ford West, SoDo, the Milk District, Ivanhoe Village and Winter Park.

We looked at local dining coverage, restaurant specialties and what Orlando residents have been recommending to put together this guide.

Here are 10 pizza places worth trying, whether you’re a longtime local or just visiting Central Florida.

1. Pizza Bruno: A Local Favorite That Helped Raise Orlando’s Pizza Game

3990 Curry Ford Road, Orlando

If you’re starting a serious Orlando pizza adventure, Pizza Bruno deserves a place near the top of the list.

The original Curry Ford restaurant specializes in wood-fired pizza, with a crust that balances a chewy interior and a lightly charred exterior.

But Pizza Bruno isn’t simply trying to duplicate a traditional Italian pizzeria.

The menu combines classic ingredients with creative toppings, giving familiar pizzas a distinctive personality.

It’s also known for garlic knots, which have developed a following of their own.

The restaurant has earned recognition in the MICHELIN Guide, and Orlando Weekly readers selected it as the best restaurant in the SoDo and Curry Ford area in the publication’s 2026 neighborhood dining poll.

What to try: A signature wood-fired pizza and an order of garlic knots.

Best for: A casual dinner, a family outing or introducing someone to Orlando’s independent pizza scene.

2. SoDough Square: Detroit-Style Pizza With Crispy Cheese Edges

SoDo area, Orlando

If you’ve never tried Detroit-style pizza, SoDough Square is an excellent place to start.

Forget the traditional round pizza.

Detroit-style pizza is rectangular, thick and airy, with cheese that extends to the edges of the pan.

As the pizza bakes, that cheese caramelizes against the sides, creating a crispy, golden crust.

The result is completely different from a New York slice.

SoDough has developed a particularly enthusiastic following among Orlando pizza fans, with residents frequently recommending it in local discussions.

And it’s easy to understand the appeal.

The pizza is substantial, the crust has plenty of texture and the cheese-covered edges are arguably the best part.

What to try: A classic Detroit-style pepperoni or cheese pizza, along with the cheesy garlic bread.

Best for: Anyone who loves a thick crust and crispy edges.

3. John & John’s: A Strong Contender for Orlando’s Best New York-Style Pizza

SoDo neighborhood, Orlando

Some people don’t want unusual toppings or experimental pizza combinations.

They just want a really good slice.

That’s where John & John’s comes in.

This neighborhood pizzeria has earned a loyal following for its New York-inspired pies.

Think thin crust, a balanced tomato sauce, melted cheese and slices that are large enough to fold.

In discussions about the best traditional pizza in Orlando, John & John’s comes up repeatedly.

It’s also a particularly good choice for someone who wants to judge a pizza by the basics rather than the number of toppings.

What to try: A classic cheese or pepperoni pizza. The vodka sauce pizza is another popular recommendation.

Best for: New York-style pizza fans and anyone who appreciates a traditional neighborhood pizzeria.

4. Black Magic Pizza: Creative Pizza With a Little Attitude

121 North Bumby Avenue, Orlando

Not every great pizza restaurant needs a conventional dining room.

Black Magic Pizza operates with a distinctly different personality in Orlando’s Milk District.

It’s known for its walk-up, takeout-oriented setup, creative pizzas and playful heavy-metal identity.

The pizza itself is serious business.

Black Magic uses flavorful dough, carefully chosen ingredients and topping combinations that go beyond the standard pepperoni-and-mushroom routine.

One popular creation is the Dr Pepperoni, featuring pepperoni and a sweet-spicy maple finish.

Another favorite is the White Iverson, which combines a garlic-ricotta base with caramelized onions and a sesame-seed crust.

The restaurant also offers several vegan pizza options.

What to try: Dr Pepperoni or White Iverson.

Best for: Adventurous pizza lovers, takeout nights and people who enjoy discovering unconventional neighborhood restaurants.

5. Prato: Wood-Fired Pizza on Winter Park’s Park Avenue

124 North Park Avenue, Winter Park

Pizza doesn’t always have to be a casual takeout experience.

Sometimes you want a good pizza in a restaurant where you can sit outside, enjoy the atmosphere and make an evening of it.

Prato delivers that kind of experience.

Located on Winter Park’s popular Park Avenue, the restaurant serves Italian-inspired cuisine, including wood-fired pizzas.

The atmosphere is lively, with a combination of indoor seating and an inviting outdoor patio.

And because it’s located in one of Central Florida’s most attractive shopping districts, dinner can easily become part of a longer outing.

Walk through Central Park.

Browse the shops.

Then settle in for pizza.

What to try: A Margherita or Diavola-style pizza.

Best for: Date nights, couples and visitors who want a more polished dining experience.

6. Ziggie’s Pizza: Thin-Crust Creativity in Ivanhoe Village

603 Virginia Drive, Orlando

If you prefer pizza with a very thin, crispy crust, Ziggie’s deserves your attention.

Located in Ivanhoe Village, this neighborhood pizza shop specializes in personal-size pies with inventive combinations.

Its approach is different from both traditional New York pizza and thick Detroit-style squares.

The crust is thin, and the toppings often combine savory, sweet and spicy flavors.

One of the most distinctive pizzas is Killa Beez, which combines ingredients such as fig jam, goat cheese, cured meats and hot honey.

It’s the kind of pizza that may sound unusual until you try it.

Ziggie’s is also well suited to a casual evening exploring the Ivanhoe Village neighborhood.

What to try: Killa Beez or one of the creative pesto-based pizzas.

Best for: Thin-crust enthusiasts and adventurous eaters.

7. Antica Pizzeria & Market: Italian-Style Pizza in Orlando’s Packing District

2105 North Orange Blossom Trail, Orlando

Here’s an excellent excuse to visit the Packing District.

Antica Pizzeria & Market operates inside the Great Southern Box Company food hall.

Its specialty is Neapolitan-style pizza, which means a relatively thin center, airy outer crust and high-temperature baking.

The pizzas are made to order, with traditional Italian flavors alongside more adventurous combinations.

Antica also offers garlic bites, a popular accompaniment to its pizzas.

The food hall setting adds another advantage.

If you’re visiting with someone who doesn’t want pizza, they can explore other vendors while you enjoy yours.

What to try: A Margherita pizza and garlic bites.

Best for: Food hall adventures, casual lunches and traditional Italian-style pizza.

8. Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza: A Pizza That Looks as Interesting as It Tastes

7541 West Sand Lake Road, Dr. Phillips

Sometimes presentation is part of the fun.

Mister O1 Extraordinary Pizza has become known for its distinctive star-shaped pizzas.

These aren’t simply ordinary round pies cut into unusual shapes.

The points of the star are folded and filled with ricotta cheese, giving the crust an additional layer of flavor.

The restaurant focuses on thin-crust artisan pizzas with Italian-inspired ingredients.

For anyone who enjoys taking photographs of interesting food, the star pizzas are certainly memorable.

But the real appeal is the combination of thin crust, cheese and carefully balanced toppings.

What to try: One of the signature star-shaped pizzas.

Best for: A fun dinner, families and anyone looking for something different in the Dr. Phillips area.

9. Antonella’s Pizzeria: A Neighborhood Pizza Stop in Winter Park

360 West Fairbanks Avenue, Winter Park

Sometimes the best pizza experience isn’t elaborate.

It’s a neighborhood pizzeria serving familiar favorites.

Antonella’s Pizzeria on Fairbanks Avenue offers New York-style pizza, along with calzones, stromboli, pasta and traditional Italian comfort food.

It’s a good option for someone who wants a straightforward slice without turning dinner into an expensive occasion.

The restaurant also serves pizza by the slice, making it convenient for a quick lunch.

And because it’s close to downtown Winter Park, it’s easy to combine a visit with shopping or an afternoon exploring the neighborhood.

What to try: A classic cheese or pepperoni slice with garlic knots.

Best for: Casual lunches, takeout and traditional pizza fans.

10. Pienezza Pizza: A New York-Style Favorite in Kissimmee

3236 John Young Parkway, Kissimmee

We couldn’t put together a Greater Orlando pizza guide without including something south of Orlando.

Pienezza Pizza, located near The Loop shopping area in Kissimmee, specializes in New York-style pizza.

It’s a practical option for residents in Osceola County who don’t want to drive all the way into downtown Orlando to find a good pie.

The restaurant serves thin-crust pizzas along with wings and other Italian-American favorites.

It also works well for families looking for an easy meal after shopping or visiting the nearby entertainment district.

What to try: A classic New York-style pepperoni pizza.

Best for: Kissimmee residents, family pizza nights and anyone who loves foldable slices.

So, Which Pizza Is Actually the Best?

That depends entirely on what you like.

Here’s how we’d narrow it down.

What Makes a Really Good Pizza?

Everyone has an opinion, but a few things separate a memorable pizza from an average one.

The crust matters. A good pizza starts with properly prepared dough. Whether you prefer thin, thick, chewy or crispy, the crust should have flavor rather than simply holding the toppings.

The sauce should complement the pizza. Too much sauce can overwhelm the cheese and crust. Too little leaves the pizza dry.

Good cheese makes a difference. Mozzarella should melt properly without turning the entire pizza into an oily mess.

Balance is important. A pizza with a dozen toppings isn’t automatically better than a simple Margherita.

And perhaps most importantly, eat it fresh whenever possible.

Pizza that’s been sitting in a delivery box for 30 minutes is rarely the same as one served straight from the oven.

Turn It Into an Orlando Pizza Adventure

Here’s a fun idea for couples, families or groups of friends.

Instead of ordering from the same place every Friday, create your own Orlando Pizza Challenge.

Choose four different pizza styles and try one each week.

Start with a New York-style slice.

Then try Detroit-style.

Follow that with Neapolitan pizza.

Finish with something creative, like a hot-honey pizza.

At each stop, rate the crust, sauce, cheese, toppings and overall experience.

You might discover that your favorite style isn’t the one you’ve been eating for years.

And you’ll have a good excuse to explore neighborhoods around Greater Orlando.

Orlando Has Become a Serious Pizza Town

For a long time, Central Florida’s restaurant reputation was dominated by theme park dining, chain restaurants and tourist-oriented establishments.

But Orlando’s independent food scene has grown considerably.

And pizza is one of the areas where that growth is easy to see.

You can find traditional Italian techniques, regional American pizza styles and restaurants experimenting with flavors that reflect the area’s diverse culinary influences.

The best part is that you don’t need to spend an entire day searching.

A great pizza might be waiting in a neighborhood you’ve driven through dozens of times.

So the next time you’re craving pizza, skip your usual order and try somewhere different.

Because the best pizza in Orlando might be the one you haven’t discovered yet.

Restaurant information reviewed October 2026. Menus, hours and prices may change. Check with each restaurant before visiting.